Forum
Community Forum
Today's Posts
FAQ & Rules
Members List

Writing
Writing Forum
Recent Posts
Critique Guidelines

Groups
YWO Social Groups
Facebook
Myspace

Chat
 
YWA

Register

Store
Support YWO
YWO Merchandise
The Book Despository
Amazon.com (US)
Amazon.co.uk (UK)
Amazon.ca (Canada)

SBS Mag


View Poll Results: What should we use to refer to comments in Literature?
"Critiques" 19 47.50%
"Reviews" 6 15.00%
I'm fine with either 15 37.50%
Voters: 40. You may not vote on this poll

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools
Old 06-27-2008, 12:37 AM View Post #1 (Link) "Critique" or "Review"?
Andy (Offline)
Administrator
 
Andy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: At home
Posts: 2,478
Points: 32
Times Thanked: 99
Shaun and I are planning some improvements to Literature. One issue is whether we should refer to literature comments as "critiques" or "reviews". Answer the poll, and give your reasons. Shaun and I have ours, but I don't want you all to be influenced or anything until you've had your say.
__________________

 
Old 06-27-2008, 12:49 AM View Post #2 (Link)
GeorgeMichael (Offline)
Freelance Writer
 
GeorgeMichael's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: No longer in a boring city!
Posts: 910
Points: 7.3
Times Thanked: 54
Honestly I've just grown used to critiques so I feel that it would be better to leave it that way
__________________
Reading List for January


Salem's Lot - Stephen King
A Game of Thrones - GRRM
The Lost Symbol - Dan Brown

If anyone is wondering, my boyfriend's internet is the absolute worst piece of shit in existence, and it causes my computer to slow down significantly anytime I enter the Chatroom. It also causes the chatroom to freeze anyway, so it's a bit futile to attempt to log in while I'm at his place.
 
Old 06-27-2008, 12:50 AM View Post #3 (Link)
Nyx (Offline)
Wordsmith
 
Nyx's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 2,737
Points: 26
Times Thanked: 142
Hm, they're synonyms so I don't think there'd be a huge difference, however I'd prefer we go along with critique as that is what most of us already refer to it as. Also because critique can be shortened to crit. Anyways, I don't see why we should change it now that mostly everyone refers to it on the site as critique.
__________________
PM for critiques and help? Yes, you may.
~~~~~~
Originally Posted by Diocletian View Post
What I don't like about this site is that there isn't enough social drama.
 
Old 06-27-2008, 12:55 AM View Post #4 (Link)
Andy (Offline)
Administrator
 
Andy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: At home
Posts: 2,478
Points: 32
Times Thanked: 99
If you want my two cents....
Spoiler:
I was thinking that newbies would be more used to the term "review" than "critique" and would get the idea better. Not much of a reason, but yeah. It went through my head.
__________________

 
Old 06-27-2008, 01:17 AM View Post #5 (Link)
Ichigo (Offline)
Freelance Writer
 
Ichigo's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Pallet Town
Posts: 1,313
Points: 20
Times Thanked: 32
Most newbs who come here have some idea what critique means though...
I think.

Either would be fine really.
__________________
"Honesty is the cornerstone of all success, without which confidence and ability to perform shall cease to exist."

PM me for Poetry crits!! I've been super neglectful of this site for so long. Put me to work.
 
Old 06-28-2008, 02:43 AM View Post #6 (Link)
Shaun (Offline)
Dead Person
 
Shaun's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Gainesville, FL
Posts: 5,691
Points: 11.33
Times Thanked: 142
Well, my two cents on this would be: isn't the point of dealing with newbs to teach them how things run around here? Lots of newbs have no idea that they're supposed to critique, doesn't mean we should let them get away with it .
__________________
The Viking Amoeba Army is here! Run for your lives!

Tumblr!

Read my published fiction and non-fiction!

And check out The World in the Satin Bag novel podcast. Help me become rich and donate!

My Random Stuff:
--The World in the Satin Bag: My science fiction, fantasy, and writing blog!
--Check out Cheese & Crackers Original and Cheese & Crackers Superheroes
--The Skiffy and Fanty Show
--Duke and Zink Do America (Political Podcast)

YWO Stuff:
--Buy Survival By Storytelling Magazine (Issue One is available!) Support fellow YWO writers!
--And don't forget to buy something from YWO's Zazzle Store!
--Follow YWO on Twitter.

Spoiler:
This is a call to arms, gather soldiers,
Time to go to war.
This is a battle song, brothers and sisters,
Time to go to war.
 
Old 06-28-2008, 09:05 PM View Post #7 (Link)
Guessed (Offline)
Scholarly Apprentice
 
Guessed's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Soggy cardboard box.
Posts: 125
Points: 10
Times Thanked: 16
"Review" and "critique" can mean very different things or very similar things. "Review" is a friendlier, warmer word, I think - but it brings with it that wrong connotation that the reviewer needs only to voice their opinion on a piece of work - maybe throw in a score. Both of those things are well and good, but a "critique" is more in-depth. It's a thorough examination of strengths and weaknesses. I think that's what we're looking for here.

I think that if a newbie doesn't understand the general concept of critiquing, we don't really want that newbie on this writing board... not to sound like an elitist. On the other hand, Shaun's right about newbies not understanding YWO's expectation of them to crit others. I, personally, was surprised to discover the heavy responsibility of each member to crit others, although I agree with the policy.
__________________
"I meant," said Ipslore bitterly, 'what is there in this world that makes living worthwhile?'
Death thought about it.
CATS, he said finally. CATS ARE NICE.
Click (There's cake. Really.)
 
Old 06-29-2008, 10:05 AM View Post #8 (Link)
Zaphkiel (Offline)
Freelance Writer
 
Zaphkiel's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: New Jersey
Posts: 1,023
Points: 30
Times Thanked: 31
I think we should stay with critique...
__________________

The stars are shining.
The full moon above me.
Why does the night pass by?
Why couldn’t it last forever?


Zaphkiel's Final Product: A Cursed Royalty
 
Old 06-29-2008, 02:31 PM View Post #9 (Link)
jordanisonfire (Offline)
Master of English
 
jordanisonfire's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: England
Posts: 3,962
Points: 30
Times Thanked: 97
When I first went on TW, which was the first writers' site I'd ever been on (before the dreaded AOL Chatroom "Writers' Corner", which should be renamed "Cliche Corner", in my opinion), I had no idea what a critique was. But after a few hours I soon got the idea. I was very nervous when I gave my first crit, which I cannot remember, because I thought I may have done it all wrong, but it turned out to be okay. But I knew what a review was. However, yes, reviews tend to be more friendly and focus more on the good side of things, unless the reviewer is reviewing something terrible. Critiques seem to be more helpful. I'm sure we'd all rather have someone being incredibly awful to us but actually helping us improve our work rather than someone praising us like Gods and never actually helping us at all. I know I would. In conclusion, I say I wouldn't mind either, it's just the newbies we should be concerned about. So, choose whichever you wish, though i don't think we should be imposing any rules which say that using the word 'critique' is banned and we should all say 'review'.
 
Old 06-29-2008, 02:40 PM View Post #10 (Link)
Andy (Offline)
Administrator
 
Andy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: At home
Posts: 2,478
Points: 32
Times Thanked: 99
Thanks for the feedback, Shadow. Very helpful!
__________________

 
Closed Thread
Thread Tools

 


All times are GMT. The time now is 01:40 PM.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7 - Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All writing Copyright © its author(s). All other material Copyright © 2007-2012 Young Writers Online unless otherwise specified.
Managed by Andrew Kukwa (Andy) and Shaun Duke (Shaun) from The World in the Satin Bag. Design by HTWoRKS.